How Did One Family's Fight Expose a Broken Medical System?

• Jul, 22 2025

In Episode 347 of "Out of the Question" host Andrea welcomes back Scott Schara, who shares the heart-wrenching journey of seeking justice for the death of his daughter Grace during a hospital stay in October 2021. Grace, who had Down syndrome, died after being administered a cocktail of drugs and allegedly receiving a Do Not Resuscitate (DNR) order without the family's consent. Despite facing daunting legal hurdles—including a hostile legal environment, limited access to expert witnesses, and institutional barriers to malpractice claims—Scott and his family pursued a wrongful death lawsuit, making history as the first COVID-related wrongful death case to reach trial in Wisconsin.The conversation dives deep into the systemic obstacles that prevent families from holding medical institutions accountable. Scott highlights how medical professionals often shield one another, how laws limit patient advocacy, and how financial and legal deterrents make it nearly impossible for victims to seek justice. The trial ultimately ended in a loss for the family, but Scott emphasizes that the exposure of corruption in both the medical and legal systems was a victory in itself. He explains that the standard of care often prioritizes institutional protocols over individual rights, creating a system that can lead to unethical treatment, especially for vulnerable populations like the disabled and elderly.Scott's message is clear: informed consent and strong advocacy are essential in today's healthcare system. He urges families to remain vigilant, not blindly trust medical authorities, and prepare themselves to protect their loved ones. With a strong faith perspective, he views Grace's story not as a tragedy alone, but as a divine call to awaken and protect others from similar fates. His ongoing mission is to reveal the dangers of incentivized healthcare and to inspire a movement for medical and spiritual awareness.

Hosted by

Andrea Schwartz

Christian education advocate, author, and mentor

Dr. Charles H. Roberts

Pastor and Podcast Host